Should I renew my Barclay Arrival Plus card?

Barclaycard, Credit cards, Travel Tales 7

This page may contain affiliates links from our advertising partners. We appreciate it when you support BaldThoughts by using our links when visiting our partners.

I received a letter in the mail from Barclay telling me that my Barclay Arrival Plus card is renewing soon.  So, I expect that the annual fee will post in the next statement cycle or two.  The card has some decent benefits, but is it worth the $89 annual fee?  Should I renew my Barclay Arrival Plus card?

Related posts:

should i renew my barclay arrival plus Barlcay Arrival and me

My old Barclay Arrival back in 2014 before the redesign.

 

Barclay Arrival Plus Benefits

The Barclay Arrival Plus benefits are pretty good:

  • Good bonus after a reasonable minimum spend
  • Annual fee of $89 is waived the first year
  • 2x miles on every purchase (equivalent to 2%)
  • Get 5% miles back on every redemption (increases cash back to 2.1%)
  • No foreign transaction fees
  • Complimentary FICO score access
  • Earn miles for sharing stories in the Barclaycard Travel Community
  • Travel accident and trip cancellation insurance

These benefits might sound impressive, but so many new cards have come out since the Arrival Plus was released.  With all of the competition, the bar has been raised and these benefits are no longer that impressive.

And when you add in the fact that the Arrival Plus downgraded the benefits a couple of years ago, the card is not as strong as it used to be:

  • Increased minimum redemption from $25 to $100
  • Reduced miles rebate from 10% to 5%
  • Eliminated TripIt Pro complimentary membership

So, the question remains, should I renew my Barclay Arrival Plus card?

should i renew my barclay arrival plus Barclaycard Arrival Plus World Elite MasterCard

 

Should I renew my Barclay Arrival Plus card?

Because of the reduced benefits, the benefits that set the Arrival Plus apart are the $500 (50,000 points) in sign-on bonus and the 2.1% cash back (when factoring in the rebate).  The problem is that I have a 2% cash back card with no annual fee from Citibank.

So, aside from the sign-on bonus, the difference is 0.1%…. and I’m limited to $100 minimum redemptions on travel spend with the Arrival Plus and an $89 annual fee vs. no minimum redemptions and no annual fee.

Just to break even compared to the no fee 2% cash back card from Citi, I would need to spend $89,000 on the Barclay Arrival Plus and redeem all of the points on travel expenses (hotel, airfare, train, cabs) that I put on the card.

$89,000!

Obviously, $89,000 is a ton of money to spend.  And you’d have to also spend money on travel expenses earning 2% that you could redeem the Arrival Plus miles towards.

The problem is that other premium cards offer 3% or more in miles and points for travel expenses.  So, you’re also losing out on those extra miles and points, which negates the benefit of the extra 0.1% from the Barclay Arrival Plus.

 

The Bald Thoughts

When asking yourself should I renew my Barclay Arrival Plus card, consider all of the pros and cons.  The card does have some good benefits, but many of those benefits can be found with other cards you may already have in your wallet.  A no-fee cash back card may be a better option for most people.  Or the extra miles and points earned from other travel cards may provide a better return on your travel spend.  You may choose to stick with the Barclay Arrival Card, but I’m pretty sure that I will not be renewing mine unless they provide a valuable retention offer.

The opinions expressed here are the author's alone and have not been reviewed or endorsed by any company or third-party, unless clearly stated otherwise. The comments on this page are not provided, reviewed, or otherwise approved by the advertiser. It is not the advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.


Liked it? Take a second to support Lee Huffman on Patreon!

About the author / 

Lee Huffman

Lee grew up loving to travel with his parents. Now he explores the world with his wife, Anna and his two children Timothy and Scarlett. He enjoys being spoiled as a Kimpton Inner Circle Member and taking full advantage of Southwest's Companion Pass. Lee wants to teach his readers how to 'Travel More. Spend Less. Live Better.' using miles, points, tips and tricks.

7 Comments

  1. askmrlee August 10, 2017 at 11:38 am -  Reply

    I too may ditch the card, but after another year. I actually would fee (slightly) guilty if I cancelled after redeeming cashing out my first year. I didn’t think the $100 travel minimum would be a big deal, but in reality it’s more of a pain.

    It’s also the closest thing to a Chip and PIN card that most people will ever see in the US (aside from a handful of credit unions).

    • Lee Huffman August 10, 2017 at 1:06 pm -  Reply

      You make a good point about the chip and pin. More banks should get on the ball with that. However, if I need chip and pin while traveling internationally, I’ll just rely on my Charles Schwab debit card.

  2. Ask me how I know August 10, 2017 at 1:21 pm -  Reply

    Uhh…why don’t you cancel it and reapply in a month or so to get a reset on the year waiver and get another 50k points? Ask my how I know you can do this, please.

    • Lee Huffman August 10, 2017 at 2:11 pm -  Reply

      Getting a new Arrival card is an option in the future. Right now I’m focused on some refinances of loans, so I don’t want any additional inquiries. Plus, I’m getting closer to being under 5/24, so I’m not sure another Arrival is worth missing out there. Definitely a lot to consider. But, for right now, I won’t be renewing there card unless I get a retention offer worthy of the annual fee.

  3. JRG August 10, 2017 at 2:54 pm -  Reply

    Be sure at let us know what retention offer you get, if any. My card is due in December and I’m thinking of cancelling.

    • Lee Huffman August 11, 2017 at 7:58 am -  Reply

      Will do. Plan on calling them this weekend.

  4. PatMike August 11, 2017 at 10:42 pm -  Reply

    I just cancelled husband’s card last week. He applied for the Jet Blue and has the Lufthansa and AA Barclay cards.
    My experience with Arrival was that I was able to churn for the 40k bonus twice.
    The $100 threshold makes this card less valuable to me.
    In the past, I’ve MSd with this card big time and got shut down, so beware of this. I also met a woman who lost 100,000 points, by a shutdown. She was saving for a big trip.
    The $25 redemption limit and the extra 10% made this card much more valuable.
    My last hurrah was to redeem for a Japan rail pass and a Spain train ticket.
    Might have husband apply again in the future, as this was our chip and PIN card.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join our community

Help BaldThoughts grow. Show your support with just $1 a month.

Best Card Offers

Travel Rewards Credit Cards

FREE Travel Advice

BaldThoughts free travel square We will develop a strategy to reach your travel dreams. Completing the form is the 1st step.

Subscribe

Sign up to receive daily news, tips, and deals!

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Archives

Categories

Subscribe

Sign up to receive daily news, tips, and deals!

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Learn How to Travel More. Spend Less. Live Better!

You have Successfully Subscribed!